erstwhile gameA little hindsight.
← Back to the puzzle

A note to the makers.

For a bug, a puzzle correction, an idea or a question, email support@erstwhile.online.

Help us find the right puzzle

Include the Daily date or practice puzzle ID, your browser and what happened. If you are reporting a price issue, include the asset and historical period. A screenshot is helpful; private financial information is not needed.

Privacy and rights reports

The same address handles privacy requests and intellectual-property concerns. For a rights report, identify the specific material and explain your relationship to the rights involved. Please include a contact address for a response.

Erstwhile Game is independently operated. We cannot provide support for other games or websites with similar names.

A quick field guide

Five years. Three decisions.

You have $10,000 in a hidden year between 2005 and 2020. Can you grow it faster than the S&P 500?

  1. 1

    Build your portfolio

    Place 10 chips across four stocks, two other assets and cash. Each chip starts at $1,000. Put up to 4 on any option, including cash.

  2. 2

    Hold or change course

    At years 2 and 4, see your positions and a new historical clue. Hold keeps your actual holdings. Rebalance sells everything: divide the current total into 10 equal chips and place them again.

  3. 3

    See where you landed

    Year 5 reveals the dates, your return and the S&P 500 fund result. See the strongest possible strategy and how your result compares with all legal strategies.

Daily changes at midnight in your device’s local time. Unlimited includes 100 practice puzzles plus previously released Daily puzzles. Gold, silver, oil, bonds and commodities use the fund proxies named in asset details. No fees, taxes or trading costs are simulated.